In 1996, Tyrone Noling was sentenced to death for aggravated murder in the 1990 double homicide of Bearnhardt and Cora Hartig at their Moff Road home in Atwater. Fully 27 years later, a new development may — or may not — produce documents to support Noling’s request for a new trial.
Noling was 18 years old at the time of the home invasion and homicides. Now middle-aged, he has won a battle to have his legal team examine 16 boxes of documents stored at the Portage County Prosecutor’s Office.
Join our community of supporters to access this article
Articles older than 30 days are available to Portager subscribers with a Plus or Premium plan. Subscriptions start at just $1/month.
Already a paid subscriber? Log in here
Plus
Get more from your email newsletter.
$1+ /month
View subscription options- Email newsletter delivered Monday, Wednesday and Friday
- Full access to The Portager website
- Participate in the community forum
- Access articles older than 30 days
- Read the publisher's comments in the email newsletter
- List of real estate transactions
- Local comic strip, Headwater Tales
- Donate one free ad per year to a local business or charity
- Print newspaper home delivery via USPS
- Sudokus and crosswords
- 20% off everything in The Portager shop
Premium
Get our print newspaper delivered.
$17 /month
$180 /year
View monthly option View yearly option- Email newsletter delivered Monday, Wednesday and Friday
- Full access to The Portager website
- Participate in the community forum
- Access articles older than 30 days
- Read the publisher's comments in the email newsletter
- List of real estate transactions
- Local comic strip, Headwater Tales
- Donate one free ad per year to a local business or charity
- Print newspaper home delivery via USPS
- Sudokus and crosswords
- 20% off everything in The Portager shop